Episode 636: Stuck in Lyme Recovery? How to Break Through Treatment Plateaus – Dr. Carolyn Mukai | LIVE from ILADS

Feeling stuck in your Lyme disease recovery? What if you're making more progress than you realize—but the daily ups and downs make it difficult to see?
In this LIVE from ILADS episode of the Tick Boot Camp Podcast, co-host Rich Johannesen welcomes back Dr. Carolyn Mukai, ND, a naturopathic physician at Tandem Clinic in Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, who specializes in Lyme disease, tick-borne infections, and complex chronic illness.
Recorded at the 2025 International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) Conference in San Antonio, Texas, this conversation explores one of the most frustrating experiences in chronic illness recovery: hitting a treatment plateau.
After appearing on Tick Boot Camp at a previous ILADS conference alongside her colleague Dr. Lynn Klassen, ND, Dr. Mukai returns as a conference presenter to discuss how practitioners can better support patients with complex, overlapping medical conditions.
She explains how tracking symptoms, measuring improvements, recognizing patterns, and reassessing treatment plans can help patients and practitioners understand whether meaningful progress is occurring.
The conversation also explores mast cell activation syndrome (MCAS), dysautonomia, hypermobility syndromes, mold-related concerns, financial barriers to treatment, and the importance of educating healthcare professionals.
Most importantly, Dr. Mukai reminds patients that recovery doesn't always follow a straight line—and sometimes recognizing progress requires looking at the bigger picture.
Meet Dr. Carolyn Mukai, ND
Dr. Carolyn Mukai is a naturopathic physician at Tandem Clinic in Vancouver, British Columbia.
She completed a two-year residency focused on vector-borne illness and complex chronic disease at Tandem Clinic.
Her clinical interests include Lyme disease, associated infections, complex chronic illness, mast cell activation syndrome, dysautonomia, hypermobility syndromes, and environmental health concerns.
Dr. Mukai also has personal experience navigating Lyme disease and chronic illness, which informs her patient-centered approach.
Alongside Dr. Lynn Klassen, she helps educate healthcare professionals through practitioner training programs designed to improve the assessment and management of complex chronic illness.
From ILADS Exhibitor to Conference Presenter
Rich begins the interview by welcoming Dr. Mukai back to Tick Boot Camp.
The two first met at a previous ILADS conference, where Dr. Mukai and Dr. Lynn Klassen were participating as exhibitors.
This year, they returned as presenters, sharing their clinical experiences and educational approaches with other healthcare professionals.
Dr. Mukai explains that education has always been central to their mission.
Whether working with patients or training practitioners, their goal is to make complicated medical conditions easier to understand and manage.
Their conference presentation explored strategies for addressing treatment plateaus in complicated vector-borne disease, including investigational adjunctive therapies.
During this interview, however, Rich focuses on a particularly important question for patients:
How can someone recognize when they've reached a plateau, and what can their healthcare team do about it?
What Is a Lyme Disease Treatment Plateau?
A treatment plateau occurs when a patient's symptoms or functioning stop showing meaningful improvement over a period of time.
For people managing Lyme disease or complex chronic illness, this can be discouraging.
A patient may initially experience improvements in fatigue, pain, cognitive function, or daily activities.
Then progress appears to slow or stop.
Rich explains that after interviewing hundreds of people affected by Lyme disease, he has noticed a recurring pattern.
Many patients describe periods of improvement followed by setbacks or stretches when they feel stuck.
Dr. Mukai agrees that this pattern is familiar in her clinical practice.
However, a plateau does not automatically mean an infection remains active or that treatment has failed.
Persistent symptoms can have multiple explanations, making careful reassessment important.
Why Recovery Doesn't Always Feel Like Progress
One of the most powerful moments in the interview comes when Dr. Mukai explains the difference between experiencing recovery day to day and looking at progress over several months.
When patients are living with symptoms every day, they naturally focus on how they feel in the moment.
A difficult morning, painful flare, or exhausting week can make previous improvements seem insignificant.
Dr. Mukai explains that when someone is focused on individual setbacks, they may struggle to recognize the larger pattern.
When you zoom in, you see the peaks and valleys. When you zoom out, you may discover an overall upward trajectory.
For example, a patient might still experience fatigue but notice that they can now complete activities that were impossible several months earlier.
Another person may continue experiencing brain fog but find that their pain has decreased or their sleep has improved.
These changes matter.
Dr. Mukai believes practitioners should help patients recognize improvements while continuing to validate the symptoms and limitations they experience.
Recovery experiences vary, and improvement cannot be guaranteed, but tracking meaningful changes can help patients make more informed decisions.
The Emotional Challenges of Treatment Plateaus
Rich asks Dr. Mukai about the emotional impact of feeling stuck.
For many patients, a plateau can bring uncertainty, frustration, and fear.
They may wonder whether their treatment is working, whether their symptoms will improve, or whether they have exhausted their options.
Dr. Mukai emphasizes that these feelings deserve acknowledgment.
Patients who are struggling may have difficulty recognizing progress, particularly when symptoms fluctuate.
She believes practitioners can help by explaining what they are observing, reviewing changes over time, and discussing realistic next steps.
The goal is not to dismiss setbacks or promise improvement.
Instead, it is to help patients feel supported and involved in decisions about their healthcare.
Tracking Lyme Disease Symptoms Every Four Weeks
One of the most practical takeaways from the interview is Dr. Mukai's structured approach to follow-up appointments.
She explains that her practice commonly reassesses patients approximately every four weeks.
During these visits, the team reviews symptoms and asks patients to estimate their overall level of improvement.
Dr. Mukai describes using percentage-based measurements.
For example, a patient might report feeling:
- 30% of their usual level of functioning
- 50% of their usual level of functioning
- 70% of their usual level of functioning
These percentages are subjective, but tracking them consistently can help reveal patterns.
A patient who reports 40% functioning during one appointment and 60% several months later may be experiencing meaningful changes even if symptoms remain.
The purpose is not to reduce someone's health to a number.
It is to create a reference point that can help patients and practitioners recognize changes over time.
Why Tracking Individual Symptoms Matters
Dr. Mukai explains that overall improvement percentages are useful, but evaluating individual symptoms can provide even more information.
For example, a patient might report the following changes between appointments:
- Fatigue: Previously severe, now moderate.
- Joint pain: Previously moderate, now mild.
- Brain fog: Still severe, with little noticeable improvement.
- Sleep quality: Previously poor, now gradually improving.
- Daily functioning: Previously very limited, now able to complete more everyday activities.
This is an illustrative example, not actual patient data from the interview.
In this example, several symptoms have improved while cognitive difficulties remain unchanged.
That distinction may help the healthcare team determine which concerns require additional investigation.
Without consistent tracking, the patient might simply report feeling unwell and overlook meaningful changes in other areas.
Dr. Mukai believes that measuring symptoms over time helps both patients and practitioners make more informed decisions.
How Practitioners Identify a Treatment Plateau
Dr. Mukai explains that her team uses patient-reported improvements, symptom assessments, and questionnaires to evaluate progress.
If a patient's reported functioning remains relatively unchanged across multiple appointments, the practitioner may consider whether a plateau has occurred.
However, a single unchanged measurement does not necessarily indicate treatment failure.
The healthcare team may need to evaluate:
- Whether symptoms have remained stable over time
- Which symptoms are improving and which are not
- Whether daily functioning has changed
- Whether new symptoms or side effects have appeared
- Whether other medical conditions require attention
- Whether the existing treatment plan remains appropriate
Dr. Mukai emphasizes that a structured process helps practitioners make more thoughtful decisions.
Rather than automatically adding treatments, clinicians can review the available information and determine whether reassessment is needed.
Questionnaires Used in Complex Chronic Illness Care
Dr. Mukai discusses using questionnaires to organize symptoms and identify patterns.
Two tools mentioned during the interview are the MSIDS questionnaire and the Jill Crista mold questionnaire.
MSIDS Questionnaire
MSIDS stands for Multiple Systemic Infectious Disease Syndrome, a framework associated with Dr. Richard Horowitz.
The questionnaire organizes symptoms and potential contributors to complex illness.
It may support discussions between patients and practitioners but does not independently diagnose Lyme disease or active coinfections.
Jill Crista Mold Questionnaire
Dr. Mukai also discusses a questionnaire associated with Dr. Jill Crista that focuses on symptoms and possible environmental exposure concerns.
This tool may help organize a patient's history and identify questions for further evaluation.
However, questionnaires cannot independently establish mold-related illness or determine the cause of symptoms.
Dr. Mukai uses these assessments as part of a broader clinical evaluation.
For more information about the MSIDS framework, explore Dr. Richard Horowitz's Tick Boot Camp doctor profile.
Lyme Disease, MCAS, Dysautonomia, and Hypermobility
Dr. Mukai explains that patients with complex chronic illness may experience symptoms involving multiple body systems.
She specifically discusses conditions that can overlap clinically with Lyme disease and other illnesses.
Mast Cell Activation Syndrome (MCAS) involves episodes of mast cell mediator release that may produce symptoms affecting several organ systems.
Dysautonomia refers to dysfunction of the autonomic nervous system, which helps regulate heart rate, blood pressure, digestion, and other automatic bodily functions.
Hypermobility syndromes involve increased joint mobility and may be associated with pain, instability, and other complications.
Dr. Mukai also discusses environmental exposure concerns, including mold-related symptoms.
These conditions have distinct diagnostic considerations and do not automatically indicate an underlying tick-borne infection.
She emphasizes that clinicians treating complex cases should be familiar with overlapping medical conditions and recognize when additional evaluation is appropriate.
Why Complex Treatment Plans Need Structure
Dr. Mukai believes individualized treatment is important, but she also emphasizes the value of a structured approach.
Patients with complex chronic illness may have several medical concerns requiring attention.
Introducing multiple interventions without a clear plan can make it difficult to determine which changes are helping or causing problems.
Dr. Mukai discusses the importance of:
- Establishing treatment priorities
- Tracking changes consistently
- Introducing interventions thoughtfully
- Monitoring symptoms and side effects
- Reassessing when progress slows
- Communicating clearly with patients
A structured process can help patients understand why a particular treatment is being considered and what outcomes their healthcare team hopes to achieve.
What Happens When Treatment Stops Working?
Rich asks Dr. Mukai how practitioners can help patients move beyond a plateau.
She explains that her team reviews the existing treatment plan and considers whether additional interventions or evaluations are appropriate.
The decision depends on the individual patient.
Sometimes the most useful step may be investigating another possible contributor to symptoms.
In other situations, the practitioner may reconsider the timing, intensity, or combination of treatments.
Dr. Mukai describes the importance of having additional options available while introducing them carefully.
Some approaches discussed during the broader ILADS presentation, including oxidative IV therapies, remain investigational for Lyme disease and have not been established as effective treatments.
The central message is that a plateau should prompt thoughtful reassessment rather than automatically assuming that more treatment is necessary.
The Financial Burden of Lyme Disease Treatment
One important topic Dr. Mukai raises is affordability.
Complex chronic illness care can involve significant expenses, including medical appointments, testing, medications, supplements, and other interventions.
Not every patient has the financial resources to pursue every available option.
Dr. Mukai explains that her team considers a patient's budget when discussing treatment decisions.
An intervention that might be considered in one situation may not be financially realistic or medically justified in another.
She describes evaluating potential benefits against costs, particularly when considering additional interventions after a plateau.
This reflects an important principle of patient-centered care: treatment plans should account for the patient's medical needs, personal priorities, and financial circumstances.
Why Practitioner Education Matters
Dr. Mukai and Dr. Lynn Klassen are committed to educating healthcare professionals about Lyme disease and complex chronic illness.
Their work at Tandem Clinic includes practitioner training designed to provide a structured approach to evaluating patients with complicated medical histories.
The educational programs are intended for healthcare professionals, including medical doctors, osteopathic physicians, naturopathic doctors, and nurse practitioners.
Topics include tick-borne infections, overlapping chronic conditions, assessment strategies, treatment planning, and ongoing patient management.
Dr. Mukai believes that expanding practitioner knowledge can help patients access more informed care.
Professional education is valuable, although individual diagnostic and treatment recommendations should always be evaluated against the available evidence and appropriate clinical standards.
How Patients Can Share These Resources With Their Doctors
Rich asks Dr. Mukai what patients can do if something discussed during the interview resonates with them but their current healthcare professional is unfamiliar with the approach.
Dr. Mukai encourages patients to share Tandem Clinic's practitioner education resources with their providers.
The clinic offers training and consultation opportunities for healthcare professionals interested in Lyme disease and complex chronic illness.
Patients can share the Tandem Clinic Practitioner Training and Consultation Program with their healthcare team.
The goal is to encourage productive conversations and help clinicians determine whether additional education or consultation would be useful.
How to Connect With Dr. Carolyn Mukai
Dr. Mukai explains that Tandem Clinic continues to accept eligible patients in British Columbia.
The clinic offers different levels of care involving naturopathic physicians, residents, and associates, with consultation available when appropriate.
Patients and practitioners can explore available services through the clinic's website.
Tandem Clinic
Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada
Visit Tandem Clinic and Explore Patient Services
Key Takeaways From Dr. Carolyn Mukai
- Treatment plateaus are challenging. Patients may feel discouraged when symptoms stop improving.
- Recovery does not always follow a straight line. Fluctuating symptoms can make progress difficult to recognize.
- Looking at the bigger picture matters. Tracking changes over time may reveal improvements that are not obvious day to day.
- Regular follow-ups provide structure. Dr. Mukai describes reassessing patients approximately every four weeks.
- Percentage-based symptom tracking can be useful. Subjective measurements may help identify trends.
- Individual symptoms deserve separate attention. Fatigue, pain, cognitive difficulties, and sleep may change at different rates.
- Questionnaires can help organize information. They support assessment but do not independently establish diagnoses.
- Complex chronic illness may involve overlapping conditions. MCAS, dysautonomia, hypermobility, and other medical concerns require appropriate evaluation.
- Treatment plans should be individualized and structured. Changes should have clear goals and appropriate monitoring.
- Financial considerations matter. Patients deserve treatment discussions that acknowledge affordability.
- Practitioner education can improve clinical awareness. Tandem Clinic provides educational resources and consultations for healthcare professionals.
- Patients deserve validation and continued support. Feeling stuck should prompt thoughtful reassessment rather than assumptions about treatment failure.
Additional Lyme Disease Resources
- International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS)
- Tick Boot Camp Doctors Podcast Collection
- Tick Boot Camp Lyme Disease Testing Resource
Final Thoughts: Recognizing Progress and Finding a Path Forward
For people living with Lyme disease and complex chronic illness, treatment plateaus can be among the most emotionally difficult parts of the journey.
Dr. Carolyn Mukai encourages patients and practitioners to look beyond individual difficult days and examine patterns over time.
Her approach emphasizes consistent symptom tracking, structured follow-up appointments, individualized care, and realistic conversations about treatment options.
She also reminds patients that recognizing improvement does not mean ignoring ongoing symptoms.
Progress deserves recognition. Setbacks deserve compassion. And persistent symptoms deserve thoughtful medical attention.
